News

Victims' advocate for the Bill Cosby survivors pins the 'complete injustice' of his release on former DA

Jennifer Storm stands with survivors of Bill Cosby and case workers outside the sentencing hearing.
Victim advocate Jennifer Storm stands with survivors of Bill Cosby and case workers outside his sentencing hearing. Provided by Jennifer Storm
Read in app

Jennifer Storm, former Victim Advocate of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, stood in the courtroom beside the survivors of sexual predator Bill Cosby in 2018 and watched him get taken away in handcuffs.

On Wednesday, she called up five victims she represented throughout the case — including Andrea Constand — and assured them that the reversal of his conviction doesn't negate the truths they shared in court.

"Those moments of justice are not lost because this court deemed something technical today that released him," Storm told Insider Wednesday. "I was trying to make sure they understand that their voices mattered, that this case alone and their bravery has led to more victims feeling safe to come forward, and more prosecutors believing and charging offenders, than we've ever seen before." 

Storm, who left her post in January, called Cosby's release from prison a "complete injustice," and blames former Montgomery County District Attorney Bruce Castor. 

The state's highest court found that a deal Castor struck with Cosby in 2005 — which promised him he wouldn't be charged in a case involving Constand who alleged he drugged and sexually assaulted her a year earlier — should have prevented his eventual prosecution. 

Castor eventually went on to represent former President Donald Trump in his second impeachment trial.

"He has consistently been on the wrong side of cases like this. When he was briefly the attorney general here in the Commonwealth, he spoke out against statute of limitation reform for sexual assault victims," Storm said. "He has historically tried to silence victims of sexual violence. I've worked with survivors of other crimes where he completely boggled cases and left victims with less than what they deserved."

Storm believes it is debatable as to whether or not Cosby actually had a "deal" with Castor. There was no nolle pros agreement — a written agreement officially declaring the office won't pursue charges against Cosby. The deal, she said, was limited to a press release and a few emails the office exchanged with Cosby. 

Regardless, if Castor had faith in Constand and the other victims, Cosby would be in prison, Storm said.

Castor didn't immediately return a message from Insider seeking comment.

"He's been an embarrassment to the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania," she said.

Bill Cosby leaving a courthouse
Bill Cosby departs the Montgomery County Courthouse on the first day of sentencing in his sexual assault trial on September 24, 2018 in Norristown, Pennsylvania.  Mark Makela/Getty Images

Wednesday's news could retraumatize all survivors, including Cosby's

Storm, who is a survivor of sexual assault herself, told Insider that Wednesday's headlines have the potential of retraumatizing victims. 

Storm said that Constand will likely release her own statement, but needed time to sit with the news. She declined to name the other four survivors she spoke with, and said she isn't speaking on their behalf. 

All survivors, though, should consider utilizing local resources, like support hotlines and rape crisis programs if they need to. 

"Anytime we see stories like this in the headlines, it rips open wounds," she said. "Whether your case is similar to Andrea's or not, anytime we see a predator walk free, it's triggering. It's damaging. It's painful. And so I would just encourage survivors to engage in whatever self-care works for them." 

Andrea Constand
Andrea Constand, who accuses Bill Cosby of sexually assaulting her, walks in a park in Toronto, December 30, 2015.  REUTERS/Mark Blinch

The reversal shouldn't stop victims from speaking up

Storm, who wrote several books about the path to overcoming sexual assault trauma, is developing a curriculum to support survivors.

She told Insider she hopes that Wednesday's ruling won't prevent victims from prosecuting their attackers.

"I think what's really important is that the facts of the case are not at dispute here," she said. "The testimony that Andrea gave, the story that she has said from day one, since 2004, when this happened, has not changed." 

What the court took issue with, she said, was with Castor's choice not to prosecute Cosby when he had the chance. 

"He failed to take this case to court," she said. "What I hope is that it empowers victims to say, 'my voice is evidence enough, and I don't care if we get a conviction or not, my day in court is my justice.'"

If you are a survivor of sexual assault, you can call the National Sexual Assault Hotline (1-800-656-4673) or visit its website to receive confidential support.

Read next

Haven hedshot
Haven Orecchio-Egresitz
Haven Orecchio-Egresitz was the senior editor overseeing Business Insider's legal affairs team. The team, which consists of several of the most senior reporters in BI's global newsroom, led the charge in covering Donald Trump's many legal issues, including his four criminal cases. As a senior criminal justice reporter at Insider's New York office, Haven wrote an award-winning six-part series on the US mental health system failures that led to police shootings of people in crisis; uncovered how a yoga guru to Hollywood elite operated an abusive international cult; reported from the NY federal court where R. Kelly was found guilty of sex crimes; and covered the Minneapolis trial of ex-officer Derek Chauvin. "Deaths in the Family," a year-long project she worked on with the Investigations Team, is the most comprehensive look at rising homicidal violence against transgender people in the US. Haven also covered Russia's unprovoked war in Ukraine and the plight of refugees from the Ukrainian border in Beregsurany and Budapest. Haven previously worked on the crime, legal affairs, and investigations beats at several newspapers in Massachusetts. While working at the Cape Cod Times, and later The Berkshire Eagle, her reporting won awards from the New England Newspaper and Press Association.Before that, Haven worked as a metro correspondent at The Boston Globe and contributed to the paper's Pulitzer Prize-winning Marathon Bombing coverage.Haven is passionate about public records, government transparency, and bagels. ExpertiseTrauma reporting, legal affairs, criminal justice, policing, courts, extremism, cults, and breaking news. Popular articles 'Love us in private and kill us in public': How transphobia turns young men into killers5 moms whose sons were killed after they called 911 for help now live with the consequences of a failed mental health system that uses police as a crutchThe Proud Boys chairman says members of the extremist organization are running for office — and you might not know if you're voting for oneSome police chiefs genuinely want to fire their bad apples. Their department's history can make that almost impossible.Before the sudden death of its leader, Ra Ma Yoga Institute was accused by some former members of being a cult. What happens now?For 48 hours a Ukrainian family walked through rubble and scorched earth to a new life