Science

Bill Gates slammed the US coronavirus testing system, calling it 'absolutely useless' because results take so long

gates testing
"The saddest thing today is that the majority of the testing is absolutely useless," Bill Gates said. Ludovic Marin/AFP via Getty Images, Brian van der Brug/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images
Read in app

Bill Gates knows, without hesitation, the first thing he'd fix about the US coronavirus response. 

"The saddest thing today is that the majority of the testing is absolutely useless, because the results don't come back in 24 hours," he told Insider in an interview. "Those are completely worthless tests."

Top government experts agree.

On Friday, Dr. Anthony Fauci from the White House Coronavirus Task Force testified before the Senate subcommittee on the coronavirus crisis and said much of the same

"It is an issue if you can't get it within a 24 to 48 hour period," Fauci said. "It, in many respects, obviates the whole purpose of doing it because if you have to wait that long — a person has already been out in the community in that period of time."

Federal estimates suggest that about 25% of the nation's coronavirus tests are falling into this "worthless" category

coronavirus testing
A person is tested for the coronavirus.  Getty

According to the US Department of Health and Human Services, about half of the nationwide testing for the coronavirus is being done in hospital labs, or at the point of care. Those tests generally come back within the useful 24 to 48 hour window. 

The other half of nationwide testing is done by commercial labs, and that can take longer, as samples are shipped off on longer treks to lab machines

"Over the past month, the percent of tests that were completed within three days by commercial labs was 45%," Admiral Brett Giroir, who is the Trump Administration's coronavirus testing czar, told reporters on a phone call Thursday. "But in the last seven days, that's over 56%. So we're seeing an improvement, week over week."

Still, this all means that roughly a quarter of the nation's coronavirus tests are taking longer than 3 days to get back results. Sometimes, the delay is longer than a week

Gates says it's an unacceptable system.

"That doesn't help at all," he said. "It's insane that we're using the finite testing capacity for delayed results. There should be no reimbursement for delayed results. They should just make sure that everybody they're testing today, it goes into the lab."

He said he's tried talking to public health experts about this, but people are often scared to speak out. 

"I've talked to various people about this," he said. "And they feel like they'll get in trouble if they say anything about improving the testing."

Read next

hilary brueck backyard headshot
Hilary Brueck
Hilary Brueck is a Health Correspondent at Business Insider, where she covers longevity and the quest to improve human aging. She also writes regularly about the complexities of diagnosing and treating cancer, the evolving landscape of GLP-1 drugs, new developments in exercise science, and expert-backed nutrition adviceIn general, she relishes any opportunity to unpack scientific discoveries or examine the latest consumer trends. Her reports have ranged from exploring how sherpas effortlessly climb into the thin air 29,029 feet above sea level to summit Mount Everest, to trudging along a Jersey shore beach with scientists fighting killer pandemic flu viruses by studying bird butts.She spoke with Dr. Anthony Fauci about his vitamin and supplement routine over a cold slice of pizza, and chatted with the world's oldest Nobel Prize winner in his basement solar lab. She also went an entire month without eating any ultra-processed foods (yes, it was time-consuming and challenging). A graduate of Columbia Journalism School and former Peace Corps Volunteer, Hilary speaks English, French, and Malagasy. Previously, Hilary reported for ABC News Radio, Fortune, Forbes, and Al Jazeera America. In her spare time, she likes to run, hike and she is also an aspiring (but very bad) surfer. If you've got a pressing health question, tip, or concern, reach out to hbrueck@bjinnox.com