Reviews Style

I tested the $23 leggings that have become one of Amazon's biggest activewear hits

A young woman stands in front of a water front and poses in black leggings, sunglasses, shoes, and a grey top
The author wearing Colorfulkoala's full-length leggings. Talia Ergas/Insider
Updated
Read in app

I'm a bit of a leggings snob. As someone who works from home, I live almost exclusively in loungewear, and leggings are my essential closet workhorse. It's tough to find a pair that's comfy enough to lounge in all day, stays put through a workout, holds up through wash and dry cycles, and looks presentable enough to wear out — especially if you're not looking to spend $90. But the Amazon-favorite Colorfulkoala legging check all those boxes and more.

A bestseller on Amazon, the Colorfulkoala High Waisted Full-Length Leggings have amassed over 53,000 glowing reviews. At $22.99 a pair, they're on the more affordable end, which made me skeptical that they wouldn't be very high-quality or durable. But I was immediately taken by the buttery soft feel, and after many washes and dry cycles, I can confirm they have kept their shape and the fabric feels the same as the day I got them.

What Colorfulkoala leggings are like to wear

Side-by-side collage. Left side illustrates a mirror pic of a person’s profile. They are wearing black leggings and a beige crop top. Right side depicts the same person in the same outfit posing except they are standing straight forward in the picture on the right.
The High Waisted Full-Length Leggings in black.  Talia Ergas/Insider

These lightweight leggings truly feel like a second skin. My favorite part is that they have a super high waist (hits just above the navel) that offers a bit of tummy smoothing without being suffocating. They stay put all day — through sitting, standing, and spin class — without rolling down or dropping. This means I'm comfortable wearing them with a cropped top. (Psst: No camel toe!) Since they're on the lightweight side, these are my go-to leggings for spring through fall, but in the winter, I opt for something a little thicker for added warmth.

Side-by-side collage. Left side depicts a person wearing green camo leggings as they squat. Right side illustrates a close up of a person standing wearing the green camo leggings.
The High Waisted Full-Length Leggings in army green splinter camo.  Talia Ergas

I own two pairs — the solid black full-length and the army green splinter camo in full-length — and there are slight differences between the solid and patterned variations. The solid, which is made of 80 percent nylon/20 percent spandex material, is almost cool to the touch, while the 75 percent polyester/25 percent spandex patterned version has a bit more of a matte finish that reminds me of Lululemon leggings.

Side-by-side collage. Left side depicts a close up of black leggings stretched out behind an outside background. Right side illustrates a young woman wearing black leggings as she poses with one leg up stretching in front of a waterfront outside.
When stretched, the black leggings still appear opaque.  Talia Ergas/Insider

A bonus for pet owners: The solid version is better than average at keeping lint and pet hair at bay (I found the patterned style to be a bit more prone to clinging bits, but still relatively not bad). Opacity is often a false promise for yoga pants, but the darker shades are actually pretty squat proof (I have not tried the lighter color range, so I can't vouch for those). 

Sizing and fit

A side by side of a woman wearing Colorfulkoala pocket leggings in the 7/8 length in black. The left depicts her posing while the right shows a closeup of the pockets on the leggings.
Insider Reviews' executive editor Sally Kaplan has the Colorfulkoala pocket leggings in the 7/8 length. At just over 5 feet tall, they fit like full-length leggings on her.  Sally Kaplan/Insider

I usually wear a medium in leggings, but a small fits me perfectly in these. At 5-foot-7, the full-length pair hits just above my ankle. They're also available in a 7/8 length, which our 5-foot-1 executive editor says fits her like a full-length legging.

The bottom line

Colorfulkoala leggings look and wear like a high-quality pair of buttery soft leggings for a fraction of the price. The flattering high-waisted fit stays in place, and the fabric maintains its shape and quality after washing and drying. These yoga pants are a great wallet-friendly option for lounging or fitness.

Read next

Talia Ergas is freelance contributor to Insider Reviews covering style, beauty, and home products. With over 10 years of experience in digital media and service journalism, Talia tells stories that help readers make smarter, more confident shopping decisions through hands-on testing, trend analysis, and expert-backed reporting.Areas of expertiseTalia's primary focus is in style and beauty, especially where comfort, aesthetics, and practicality overlap. Since taking her career fully remote, she's come to rely on chic loungewear that transitions seamlessly from her home office to the outside world.Talia also has extensive experience in home, travel, and lifestyle coverage. Her work in these areas highlights products designed to streamline routines, enhance living spaces, and perform well on the road.ExperienceTalia previously worked as a senior lifestyle editor at NBCUniversal’s BravoTV.com, leading digital coverage across all lifestyle categories. Earlier in her career, Talia held editorial roles at Us Weekly and worked in publishing and media publicity, developing a well-rounded perspective on consumer trends and brand strategy.Why you can trust Talia"I believe products should genuinely make everyday life easier, more comfortable, and more enjoyable — not just fill space in your closet or home. I have tested and reviewed hundreds of items and services, ranging from budget-friendly leggings to cosmetic injectables and luxury window treatments," according to Talia. "My reviews emphasize practical benefits and long-term value, so readers can make informed choices and skip purchases that won’t actually serve them."EducationTalia holds a BA from New York University, where she majored in journalism and sociology and minored in creative writing. She graduated summa cum laude as a Presidential Honors Scholar.Outside of workWhen she's not testing products or writing, Talia is enjoying life in the Hudson Valley of New York with her husband and three rescue kitties. Her hobbies include antiquing, exploring local farmers' markets, experimenting with home upgrades, and traveling the globe.Connect with Talia via LinkedIn, through her website, or on Instagram