We're not quite through winter yet, but I'm confident the worst of it is behind us. It's warm enough that I just broke out my favorite ballet flats from Quince, and I'm thrilled that they're still in good shape — but mostly, I'm just thrilled I finally get to wear something other than boots.
I'm an avid collector of flats. My rotation ranges from luxury pairs I save for special occasions, to wear-around-town flats made to slip on and go. This'll be my third season in a row wearing my Quince Italian Leather Glove Ballet Flats, which look nearly identical to Everlane Day Gloves. The key distinction is that Quince's cost $80 less.
Quince's take on Everlane's Day Glove Flat is crafted with the same kind of buttery-soft, pliable leather that made its originator so popular.
"They wear beautifully, are super easy to clean (just wipe them down with a damp cloth and maybe a little hand soap if necessary), and they mold to your feet like malleable leather socks," says Insider Reviews executive editor Sally Kaplan.
Not all Quince dupes are worth it — but these flats are an exception
I haven't been precious about their upkeep, but my Quince Glove Ballet Flats still feel as great as the day I put them on. In fact, similar to the Day Gloves, they get more comfortable the more you wear them, with a high vamp for a secure, glove-like fit and supple Italian leather that feels soft from the first wear.
I started testing out Quince clothing a couple years ago, when shoes were still a pretty new category for the brand. Not all of Quince's shoes (or leather goods in general) are very good — as a rule, I avoid the shade "Cognac" or any design that's too structured. But for simple silhouettes like this, Quince offers a solid budget-friendly alternative.
Everlane perfected the design, but Quince made it more accessible
Everlane's Day Gloves come in many more colors than Quince, and their leather is a bit thicker and more rigid. I've walked miles in mine and they took absolutely no time to break in (which is really rare for leather dress shoes). Everlane also introduced me to the idea that good flats should have ventilation holes — a piece of knowledge I really could've used back in middle school when all my flats smelled liked sweaty feet.
It appears both pairs are made either in Vietnam or China and Vietnam. Unfortunately, whether it's due to tariffs or other economic factors, I've witnessed Everlane's prices skyrocket, while Quince's have remained steady. My search for a reasonably priced alternative to Everlane's modern basics is what drew me to Quince in the first place.
The bottom line
The simple silhouette and neutral tone of these shoes pairs with everything in my closet, which is helpful at a time of year when the forecast could go any direction. I still say you should proceed with caution when shopping Quince's "affordable luxury," but to me, its Glove Ballet Flats are a perfect example of a dupe done right.
Learn more about how the Reviews team tests shoes at BI.
You can purchase logo and accolade licensing to this story here.
Disclosure: Written and researched by the Insider Reviews team. We highlight products and services you might find interesting. If you buy them, we may get a small share of the revenue from the sale from our partners. We may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product is featured or recommended. We operate independently from our advertising team. We welcome your feedback. Email us at reviews@bjinnox.com.
