Finance

The Tesla Model 3 has one feature that gives it an edge over other sedans

Tesla Model 3
The Model 3 has a trunk and a "frunk." Hollis Johnson/Business Insider
Read in app
  • The Tesla Model 3 is a sedan, not an SUV.
  • A selling point of SUVs is cargo capacity.
  • But the Tesla Model 3 has extra space that can add to its gear-hauling credibility.

In some respects, the new Tesla Model 3 sedan is the wrong car for the current SUV-mad market in the US.

Americans are buying lots of compact SUVs. In fact, some automakers now think that a structural change has occurred and that SUVs have completely displaced passenger cars. If you want to buy or lease, you can start with a small SUV and never look back.

Tesla plans to roll out a compact SUV, the Model Y, but until then, we have to content ourselves with the four-door.

The Model 3 has a conventional, manually operated trunk that is reasonably roomy. But compared with the cargo hatch of a compact SUV, the Model 3 looks a bit meager. That is until you get the Tesla's secret cargo weapon: the frunk!

Read on.

The Model 3! It's smaller than the Model S sedan, to be sure. But ...

Tesla Model 3
The Tesla Model 3 cruising around New Jersey. Hollis Johnson/Business Insider

It has a decent-sized trunk that could swallow up a lot of equipment.

A red Tesla is pictured next to a sidewalk with the back trunk open.
Hollis Johnson/Business Insider

And of course a front trunk, or "frunk."

Tesla Model 3
The Tesla Model 3 has a spacious frunk. Hollis Johnson/Business Insider

The total cargo capacity for the Model 3 is 15 cubic feet.

Tesla's can have the extra space up front because all-electric cars don't have a engine under the hood.

Here's the rear cargo area of a Model S.

Tesla Road Trip 2016
Matthew DeBord/Business Insider

And here's the frunk in the Model S.

A green bag is pictured in the front trunk of a Tesla.
Matthew DeBord/Business Insider

The Model S offers 30 cubic feet in total.

Moving right along, here's the rear cargo area of Model X SUV.

Tesla Model X Road Trip
Matthew DeBord/BI

And the Model X frunk.

Tesla Model X Road Trip
The Tesla Model X also has a spacious frunk. Matthew DeBord/BI

In total, a whopping 88 cubic feet of capacity for the Model X.

On paper, the Tesla Model X looks like it could handle as much as the Toyota Sienna minivan. But in practice, I don't think I could pack five kids' camp gear into the X.

Toyota Sienna
Matthew DeBord/BI

Maxed out, with the third row down, the Sienna can offer 150 cubic feet.

Just to be clear, you can put all kinds of things in the cargo area of a conventional compact SUV. Nissan even let me borrow its "Rogue Dogue" concept model.

Rogue Dogue
Matthew DeBord/BI

Read the review. The Rogue Dogue isn't a car you can buy — Nissan just did it as a car-show special.

Here's a BMW X1. There's more space back there, so for longer jaunts, the X1 beats the Model 3.

BMW X1
Matthew DeBord/BI

Total capacity is close to 30 cubic feet for the X1.

The bottom line is that for day-to-day use, the Model 3 can perform about the same as a compact SUV.

Tesla Model 3
Hollis Johnson/Business Insider

However, if you need to routinely strike out on long weekends with four or five passengers, the Model 3 would show the strain. 

That said, the fastback design is far more elegant and sporty that what you'd get in a compact SUV, with an upswinging hatch.

Read next

Matthew is a Business Insider senior correspondent who covers transportation (and chess, guitars, home-audio equipment, cocktails, and sometimes classic rock). His focus is the global auto industry, including Tesla, a company he has chronicled since 2007. He also looks after Business Insider's annual Car of the Year award, announced every fall. He's written for The New York Times, Slate, The Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, HuffPost, and CBS Interactive. He's commented on the auto industry for a variety of media outlets, including Sirius XM, MSNBC, Radio France, KPCC, and KCRW.  DeBord won the 2018 Ken Purdy Award from the International Motor Press Association. He's taught at New York University's Stern School of Business and the Marshall School of Business at the University of Southern California. His book "Return to Glory: The Story of Ford's Revival and Victory at the Toughest Race in the World" was published in 2017 by Atlantic Monthly Press and came out in paperback in June 2018. In the New York Times Book Review, Jonathan Kellerman called it a "page-turning synthesis of business book and adventure saga."