News

A cocktail of weird Caribbean weather is making Hurricane Dorian's path especially hard to predict

Hurricane Dorian approaches the coast of Florida, U.S. in this August 29, 2019 NASA handout satellite image.  NASA/Handout via REUTERS
Hurricane Dorian approaches the coast of Florida Reuters
Read in app

Hurricane Dorian is sweeping across the Atlantic Ocean on its way to the Bahamas and Florida, where it is expected to make landfall as a Category 4 storm on Monday. 

It's currently a Category 3 hurricane, with wind speeds of 115 miles per hour. By the time Dorian hits Florida's eastern coast, its wind speeds are expected to reach 140 miles per hour — enough to damage homes, down power lines, and render neighborhoods unlivable for weeks or months. 

Current projections suggest the eye of the storm could make landfall near West Palm Beach, Florida, and it may first pass over the Bahamas, but Dorian's exact path is still highly uncertain.

Predicting where the storm could make landfall has been challenging for forecasters because of a cocktail of weather conditions in the Caribbean, including warm water and an area of high pressure in the atmosphere. Here's what we know so far and why information is still limited.

Hurricane Dorian's path has shifted

Forecasters initially thought Hurricane Dorian could hit Puerto Rico on Wednesday, which prompted President Donald Trump to declare approve an emergency declaration for the US territory on Tuesday. Instead, the storm shifted east toward the Virgin Islands, causing widespread blackouts in St. Thomas and St. John and sporadic power outages in St. Croix. 

Hurricanes like Dorian start out over warm ocean water near the equator, where the sea's surface temperature is at least 80 degrees and the air is humid. The rising moisture creates a cluster of thunderstorms, which form a vortex, like water circling a drain.

The churning winds then create an area of low pressure over the ocean's surface, which allows more air to enter. Once the winds in that spinning storm system reach 74 miles per hour, a hurricane has formed.

how hurricane forms infographic
Shayanne Gal/Business Insider

In Dorian's case, the storm system is lopsided, with a large cluster of thunderstorms pulling the hurricane east. This allowed the hurricane to avoid passing over the mountains of Puerto Rico, which would have cut off its supply of moisture and heat and reduced its intensity. 

On Friday, the National Hurricane Center (NHC) said that most reliable hurricane models agree that Dorian will move west and pass near or directly over the Bahamas on Sunday. But after that, the NHC said, predictive models disagree about exactly when and where the storm will turn toward the US.

Caribbean weather makes predicting Dorian's landfall difficult

At the moment, Dorian is "very gradually turning toward the left," according to the NHC. That behavior is strange, since tropical cyclones passing through the same location typically re-curve to the right.  

The reason for this odd pattern is a pocket of high atmospheric pressure called the Bermuda High, which essentially acts like a road block that pushes the storm in a new direction. If the Bermuda High is strong (the more likely scenario), that would push Dorian toward the Florida Peninsula. If it's weak, it could steer the hurricane toward Georgia and the Carolinas. 

Figuring out how a storm intensifies is "a vexing problem," Brian Haus, a researcher who simulates hurricanes at the University of Miami, told Business Insider. 

"It's pretty well understood that if the water is warmer and it's causing more moist air to come up, you have the potential of a storm to grow quickly and intensely," Haus said. "The question is how much that's going to happen."

As Dorian passes through the Gulf Stream, the warm water there will cause the hurricane to gain strength. But its severity will also depend on whether it passes over the Bahamas' northernmost islands or continues to hover over warm water.

 

 

The storm could also intensify due to shifts in wind shear — the change in wind speed or direction that comes with a higher altitude. Dorian's wind shear is expected to weaken as it approaches Florida, meaning the storm is likely to get worse.

"Uncertainty is always a tough thing to communicate," Haus said. "I would love to know exactly where this storm is going to go, how strong it's going to be, and what that means for my house in Miami."

Read next

Aria Bendix was formerly a senior reporter at Insider, covering science and health. She wrote predominantly about the COVID-19 pandemic. In March 2020, she broke the news that the CDC had unnecessarily delayed coronavirus testing for more than two weeks by failing to communicate with state labs. Then in May 2020, she broke the news that some COVID-19 patients were developing long-lasting symptoms (now known as long COVID). In addition to COVID-19, Aria reported on environmental toxins and diseases such as autism and Alzheimer's. Her feature stories revealed harmful levels of lead in drinking water in Newark, New Jersey, and cancer and chronic coughs among residents of a former nuclear training site in San Francisco. She often appeared on radio shows, podcasts, and television to discuss her work. Aria was previously an Assistant Editor at The Atlantic and an in-house journalist at New York University. She holds a bachelor's degree from Harvard and a Master of Fine Arts from The New School.