Health

I tracked my diet for a week to see if I could get enough nutrients without taking supplements

Composite image of Insider reporter Allana Akhtar alongside a plate of chicken and veggies
I made sure to consume the recommended five to eleven servings of fruits and vegetables to get the vitamins and minerals I need. Allana Akhtar/Insider
Read in app

Americans are buying up supplements, but dietitians say they're better off investing that money in fruits and vegetables.

A bowl of strawberries, pineapple, and blueberries
Allana Akhtar/Insider

Recent research hasn't found evidence dietary supplements prevent against heart disease, cancer, or fractures — and taking too many can cause serious health problems. But some supplement users say they think getting enough nutrients from food is a daunting task.

The standard American diet is generally high in red meat and processed foods and low in fiber. Experts previously told Insider the diet provides enough of vitamins like A, C, B and zinc.

To see how easy it is to get your recommended daily nutrients from food, I recorded every meal I ate for five days and used the MyFitnessPal app to log the amount of fiber, potassium, vitamin A, vitamin C, calcium, and iron my meals provided. 

I reviewed my results with Kirstin Vollrath, a registered dietitian and professor at the University of Houston's Department of Health and Human Performance. 

Though I learned I consumed more than enough vitamin A and vitamin C and could use a little more calcium, Vollrath said you don't need to track the number of nutrients you eat as long as you're consuming a balanced diet — and you don't need to take supplements, either.

I used MyFitnessPal to track the nutrients in my food.

MyFitnessPal screenshot that shows part of a lunch and dinner
Allana Akhtar/Insider

I began my week-long experiment by tracking all my foods, plus how much I was eating, on the MyFitnessPal app. MyFitnessPal allows you to search for foods that other users have already entered, including information on calories and nutrients. 

However, this is not always an accurate measure of nutrition, Vollrath said. The calorie and nutrition information about certain foods isn't always accurate because much of it is crowdsourced by app users.

Foods with a green checkmark have been verified by the MyFitnessPal team, the company told Insider in a statement.

"[MyFitnessPal] may have 20 different options for a particular item, say mashed potatoes," Vollrath said. "Well, depending on how you make those mashed potatoes, it's gonna make a big difference in how many calories or other nutrients are in that half a cup of mashed potatoes."

That meant my nutrient log was more of an estimate rather than a true measurement, but useful for giving me a general idea of my nutrient intake.

My first day was protein-packed. I ate Greek yogurt, whey protein powder, chicken, and salmon.

Greek yogurt with whey protein powder, orange slices, and a plum
Allana Akhtar/Insider

Breakfast: Babybel cheese, 1 clementine, 2 eggs
Lunch: Half a cup of cauliflower rice, half a cup Basmati rice, 1 salmon fillet 
Snack: Half of a whey protein scoop, .5 cup of yogurt with a plum and half an orange
Dinner: Half a cup cauliflower rice, half a cup Basmati rice, 1 chicken breast, Pico de Gallo (red onion, pepper, tomato) 

Nutrients:

  • 102g fiber
  • 1,499 mg potassium
  • 45mg vitamin A
  • 248mg vitamin C
  • 51mg calcium
  • 33mg iron

I balanced leftover biryani, a Pakistani staple, with a cup and a half of salad on the second day.

Salad with biryani
Allana Akhtar/Insider

Breakfast: Two large eggs
Lunch: Turkey patty, one cup of rice, one cup of roasted green beans
Snack: Babybel cheese, 1 orange
Dinner: A cup and a half of biryani, half a cup of roasted eggplant curry, a tablespoon of yogurt, salad (1.5 cups of greens, half a cup of white beans, cucumber, tomato) 

Nutrition:

  • 38g fiber
  • 2,404mg potassium 
  • 163mg vitamin A
  • 225mg vitamin C
  • 53mg Calcium
  • 87mg iron

The third day I knew I'd be going out to eat, so I made sure to load up on fruits and veggies during the start of the day.

Zucchini, fish, rice and salad
Allana Akhtar/Insider

Breakfast: 2 eggs, 1 apple
Lunch: 2/3 cup  of sauteed zucchini, 1 tilapia fillet, half a cup of cauliflower rice mixed with half a cup biryani, side salad (1 cup mixed greens, tomato, orange pepper, kidney beans)
Snack: Coconut Chobani, 1 apple
Dinner: Chicken ramen (from a restaurant)

Nutrition:

  • 22g fiber
  • 1257mg potassium
  • 107mg vitamin A
  • 347mg vitamin C
  • 69mg calcium
  • 25mg iron

I went to Trader Joe's on the fourth day and went to town on their frozen tamales and pre-marinated chicken.

Trader Joe's chicken, carrots, salad
Allana Akhtar/Insider

Breakfast: Nothing
Lunch: Salad (1 cup mixed greens, kidney beans, red orange yellow peppers), roasted rainbow carrots, Trader Joe's seasoned chicken breast, 1.5 cups of basmati rice
Snack: Plum
Dinner: Trader Joe's chicken tamales 

Nutrition: 

  • 38g fiber
  • 2,851mg potassium
  • 1185mg vitamin A
  • 363mg vitamin C
  • 36mg calcium
  • 74mg iron

Since I meal-prepped on the fourth day, my fifth day consisted of much of the same food — including a second helping of a frozen Trader Joe's tamale.

Trader Joe's tamales
Allana Akhtar/Insider

Breakfast: 2 hard boiled eggs
Lunch: Salad (1 cup mixed greens, kidney beans, red orange yellow peppers), roasted rainbow carrots, Trader Joe's seasoned chicken breast, 1.5 cups of basmati rice 
Snack: Nothing 
Dinner: Trader Joe's chicken tamales, roasted carrots  

Nutrition: 

  • 31g fiber
  • 1,921mg potassium
  • 90mg vitamin A
  • 258mg vitamin C
  • 31mg calcium
  • 67mg iron

On average, I consumed about what I needed for each nutrient except calcium.

MyFitnessPal screenshot
An example of what the daily nutrient breakdown looks like on MyFitnessPal. Allana Akhtar/Insider

Average Daily Fiber: 46g

I was happy to learn I ate nearly double the amount of fiber recommended for women each day, which is 21 to 25 grams, according to Mayo Clinic

Average Daily Potassium: 1,986mg

My potassium intake this week was a bit low, as the National Institutes of Health recommends women get 2,600 mg a day and I ate just below 2,000.

Average Daily Vitamin A: 318mg

I was eating more vitamin A than I needed, likely from the peppers and eggs I ate almost everyday. The NIH recommends women get 700 micrograms of vitamin A, which is one thousanth of a milligram — meaning I was getting 45,000% more of the nutrient than I needed.

Average Daily Vitamin C: 288mg

I again ate much more vitamin C this week than I needed to. The NIH recommends adult women get 75 mg of vitamin C, meaning I consumed more than 300% of what I needed. 

Average Daily Calcium: 48mg

My calcium intake was very low compared to the other nutrients I recorded. The NIH recommends adult women get 1,200 mg, so I only consumed 4% of what I needed. I could have eaten more dairy and spinach last week to bring my intake up. 

Average Daily Iron: 57mg 

I ate more iron than I needed to last week — the NIH recommends adult women get 18 mg and I consumed about triple that amount. 

A dietitian said as long as I consumed a balanced, diverse diet, I don't have to track my nutrients.

Chicken, rice, vegetables
Allana Akhtar/Insider

Overall, Vollrath said she was not concerned about me missing my daily nutrient recommendations because I ate enough servings of fruits and vegetables on most days, and generally tried to eat balanced meals. 

The USDA recommends eating a plate of food that's half fruits and veggies, about a quarter protein, a quarter grains, and some dairy source on the side. 

My vitamin C was high last week compared to potassium, but that might have been because I bought oranges instead of bananas at the grocery store. I regularly eat both fruits, meaning I likely consume the recommended amount of both vitamin C if I average out my daily intake for months or a year. 

"As long as you're eating a variety of foods, you're meeting more your body's needs," Vollrath said. "You don't have to track any of that stuff."

Read next

Allana Akhtar was a senior health reporter for Insider, where she covers the emerging wellness industry and general health topics. During the COVID-19 pandemic, Allana wrote extensively about nurses, mask mandates, the vaccine rollout, and disparities in access to health. Her articles include features on nurses needing to re-use PPE in the early days of the pandemic, ones who struggled to get paid time off after getting COVID-19, and those who left bedside care after grueling pandemic working conditions. Allana also spoke to flight attendants and retail workers who faced violence as they enforced mask mandates, and community health workers who said they struggled to receive equitable vaccine access during the initial rollout. Allana now reports on emerging trends within the wellness industry, including the Westernization of indigenous medicine and dangerous wellness trends spread through social media. She also writes about plastic surgery, racial disparities in healthcare, and breaking health news. Allana has won numerous awards for her work, including the Best News Story by the Michigan Press Association in 2015, Best Reporter Covering Nurses in 2019, and the Morris and Lola Wasserstein Award for her contribution to the the University of Michigan's student paper as an Honors student. Before Insider, Allana wrote for USA TODAY, US News & World Report, Money Magazine, Health Magazine, Jalopnik, and more. You can email her at aakhtar@bjinnox.com, call/text her at (646) 376-6058, or follow her on Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, and LinkedIn. Secure tips line: Signal # 248 760 0208'We're grossly unprepared': Nurses share their frustration as the coronavirus spreads with little direction from the government or hospitals on how to mitigate it'Sexy nurse' costumes demean one of the most in-demand professions in American life — and they're a bestseller on Amazon right nowFlight attendants describe 'unprecedented' violence as travel returns and passenger aggression soarsG/O Media fired a queer employee of color who wore crop tops, shorts, and heels to work, violating a brand-new dress code that others say they routinely violated without being punishedContractors at controversial startup Rev say they worked long hours for little pay, feared they could lose their job at any time, and had to transcribe interviews with sexual-abuse survivors without warning