Military & Defense

A Harvard economics professor wants Bill Ackman to know that two wrongs don't make a right

Jason Furman (left) and Bill Ackman (right).
Jason Furman (left) and Bill Ackman (right). T.J. Kirkpatrick via Getty Images; Bryan Bedder via Getty Images
Read in app

A Harvard economics professor has criticized calls from executives like Bill Ackman to publicly out students who blamed Israel for Hamas attacks.

Jason Furman, who was an Obama-era economic advisor, argued that those calling for students to be outed and shamed should bear in mind that "two wrongs do not make a right."

Furman was weighing in on the fallout from the controversial joint statement from the Harvard Palestine Solidarity Groups. This statement, issued by multiple Harvard student groups, held the "Israeli regime entirely responsible for all unfolding violence." 

"Publishing lists of students and personal information under the headings 'terrorist,' 'genocidal murderer' and 'antisemite' is just wrong in any circumstance, and especially when many of the people named have nothing to do with the statement," Jason Furman wrote in a post on X, formerly known as Twitter, on Wednesday. 

"I admire @BillAckman, including for his efforts to exonerate the innocent," Furman added in a subsequent X post on Wednesday. "We may not agree on the definition of guilt here or the appropriate sentence. But I would hope that he & others would at least take more care in condemning people that even he would consider innocent." 

On Tuesday, Ackman called on Harvard to release the names of students who had signed a pro-Hamas letter so that he and other CEOs wouldn't "inadvertently hire" them.

Ackman later on Tuesday doubled down on his calls for the names to be released, saying that the students "shouldn't hide behind a Harvard-branded corporation while doing so anonymously."

At least five of the original 34 student groups who signed the letter have withdrawn their endorsements, per a Tuesday report by The Harvard Crimson. 

The Harvard Crimson's report added that some students had been doxed over the letter, with at least four websites publishing the personal information of members from the student organizations that were involved.  

Ackman defended his calls to name the students on Wednesday, writing in an X post that "it is not harassment to seek to understand the character of the candidates that you are considering for employment."

"If you have made a mistake, acknowledge it, and immediately correct your mistaken actions," Ackman wrote. "Public statements made by organizations of which you are a member can have a material negative impact on your reputation."

Representatives for Furman did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Insider sent outside regular business hours.

Read next

Kwan Wei Kevin Tan
Kwan Wei Kevin Tan
Kevin was a reporter at Business Insider's Singapore bureau. He reported primarily on the ins and outs of the business world, whether it be breaking news, covering CEO moves, tracking quarterly earnings, or writing explainers.He also covered careers and workplace issues, and has written about career transitions, the FIRE lifestyle, the college internship arms race, and the job hunt struggles faced by computer science majors.BackgroundKevin joined Business Insider's Singapore bureau in 2023. Before that, he was a civil servant at Singapore's Ministry of Sustainability and the Environment. He was appointed to the Singapore government's Public Service Leadership Programme, a talent development programme that develops capable and talented individuals for key leadership positions in the public service.Kevin’s journalism career began in college, where he first worked as a researcher for Channel NewsAsia and The Economist, and later as an intern reporter at Bloomberg News. In 2017, the Queen Elizabeth Diamond Jubilee Trust awarded him the Leading Change Journalism Bursary. His stories have appeared in numerous publications, including Fortune, The Japan Times, and The Edge Singapore.Kevin holds a bachelor’s degree in business administration from the National University of Singapore, where he was an NUS Merit Scholar. He was also the recipient of the PwC Whole Leadership Award, the NTUC Income Prize, the CFA Singapore Prize, and the Outstanding Undergraduate Researcher Prize.