Business Insider

Millennials aren't buying homes, and it might not be because they can't afford them: Some actually prefer to rent instead

houses
Big houses are becoming a thing of the past. earleliason/Getty Images
Read in app

Millennials are renting longer — but it's not always because they can't afford to buy a house.

Some millennials prefer to rent instead of buy, and developers are creating communities of single-family rental homes to meet this growing demand, reported Diana Olick for CNBC.

Consider AVH Communities, which partnered with Bristol Group to build a gated community called Pradera in San Antonio, Texas, which consists of 250 new three- and four-bedroom homes that rent for $1,800 to $2,300 a month, Olick wrote. The average annual household income of Pradera's residents exceeds $100,000.

"We think there's a major shift in the demographics. Empty nesters are done taking care of their homes. They want to downsize, they want portability, mobility in the lease," AVH founder and CEO Mark Wolf told Olick. "The millennial household formation, they're not really dialed into taking care of a home, they want to go out and do the same thing that the boomers are doing, which is enjoy life, not work hard for their house."

In 2018, the number of single-family homes built for rent — 43,000 — hit a peak for the first time in nearly 40 years, reported Olick, citing the National Association of Home Builders. 

Both millennials and older generations Olick spoke to said they didn't want to deal with the hidden costs of homeownership — renting is an easier way of life for them. 

That's because homebuyers often need a bigger budget than they anticipate: New furniture, monthly fees such as property tax and homeowner's insurance, and repairs can tack on unexpected expenses.

Read more: 10 hard truths no one tells you about buying a house

Millennials are changing the American Dream

Owning a house with a white picket fence is no longer one of the defining parts of the American Dream, according to Olick. But millennials aren't just ushering in a new type of American Dream — by choosing to rent instead of buy, they're also changing what homeownership in America looks like.

For one, there's the matter of house size: Baby boomers, whose kids are now grown, are putting their large houses up for sale. But millennials don't want them, preferring smaller homes instead, reported Candace Taylor for The Wall Street Journal.

And regardless of whether millennials are choosing to rent homes because it's convenient or resorting to renting because they can't afford a down payment, they collectively represent a large cohort of their generation who are renting for longer. In some cities in the US, prospective homebuyers have to save for nearly a decade for a 20% down payment.

Some millennials are waiting so long to buy homes that they're bypassing the need for a starter home altogether. It doesn't help that starter homes are scarce on the market — and real-estate investors are swooping in with all-cash offers, proving to be tough competition for millennials, as Ben Casselman and Conor Dougherty reported for The New York Times.

Whether it's by choice or force, renting seems to be making its way into the new American Dream.

Are you a millennial who has chosen to rent, buy, or live in an alternate type of housing? Email this reporter at hhoffower@bjinnox.com to share your story.

Read the full article at CNBC »

Read next

Hillary focuses on the intersection of youth culture and wealth, reporting on the lifestyles and economics of millennials and Gen Z. She covers trends in how these generations are living and spending and examines how the economy is shaping them and their financial behaviors She also reports on consumer spending and New York City's economy, and previously wrote about the ultrarich and personal finance at Insider before joining its economy team. Basically, she's written about money from every angle you can imagine. Inside the epicenter of America's Great Resignation: Kentuckians lay out the 4 forces driving the state's labor shortage — and explain why it's here to stay Millennial New Yorkers are ditching basements and roommates for luxury apartments at $1,000-plus discounts The world's youngest self-made billionaire hopes to power every future self-driving car with a technology that Elon Musk says is 'doomed' Tiffany and the Trumps: Insiders describe how the president's younger daughter has charted what they say is a distant relationship with her father and come to terms with having America's most divisive last name Inside the French Riviera's pandemic party problem Yachting insiders detail the rampant sexual harassment aboard million-dollar ships, where crew members are promised a glamorous lifestyle and can instead find themselves trapped at sea with no one to turn to Millennials came limping out of the Great Recession with massive student debt and crippled finances. Here's what the generation is up against if the coronavirus triggers another recession.