News

Rejections for standard work-visas have shot up under the Trump administration, but some companies have avoided the trend

donald trump border wall prototypes
President Donald Trump reviews border wall prototypes, Tuesday, March 13, 2018, in San Diego. Associated Press/Evan Vucci
Read in app

President Donald Trump's administration has ramped up scrutiny of visas for foreign skilled workers, rejecting more H-1B requests and requiring extra evidence to process thousands of applications, according to government data released Friday.

In the fourth-quarter of 2018, US Citizenship and Immigration Services issued requests for evidence in 60% of H-1B applications submitted by companies on behalf of their employees, up from 46% in 2017 and 28% in 2016, according to a report from the agency.  

The agency has more than doubled the instances in which it asks for additional supporting information over the last two years – it made 26,799 such requests in the last quarter of 2016, compared with more than 60,000 in last quarter of 2018. 

The application-approval rate for H-1B visas has also plummeted, declining to 76% in the fourth quarter of 2018, compared with 83% in 2017 and 92% in 2016.

The H-1B program, which allots temporary visas to foreign workers with specialized skills, has frequently come under fire from the Trump administration, which has criticized companies of abusing it to hire cheap, foreign workers at the expense of Americans.

The agency hasn't hidden its intentions of overhauling the program and applying more thorough scrutiny in an effort to ensure US workers aren't getting short-shrift from employers. 

“As part of our efforts to fulfill President Trump’s ‘Buy American and Hire American’ executive order, USCIS has made a series of reforms designed to protect U.S. workers, increase our confidence in the eligibility of those who receive benefits, cut down on frivolous petitions and improve the integrity and efficiency of the immigration-petition process,” USCIS spokeswoman Jessica Collins told The Wall Street Journal

The agency says the top reasons it requests additional evidence for applications are:

  • The application didn't establish the job qualifies as a "specialty occupation."
  • The employer didn't establish a valid relationship with the employee they'd applied on behalf of. 
  • The application failed to show the employer had specific assignments for the specialty role for the employee that would last the duration of their tenure. 

Tech companies tend to be the most voracious consumers of H-1B visas, and that trend hasn't changed, according to USCIS data.

But some companies are having more success navigating the administration's reforms and enhanced vetting than others. 

IT-services companies Capgemini, Cognizant Technologies, and Infosys – three of the five most-active applicants – saw the lowest success rates, earning approvals on 60%, 68%, and 74% of their petitions, respectively, during USCIS' 2018 fiscal year.

Some companies had near-perfect approval rates: Microsoft, Apple, Google, Intel, and Facebook each scored 99% success rates.

Michelle Mark contributed to this report.

Read next

Photo of Alex Morrell
Alex Morrell
Alex Morrell was a senior correspondent at Business Insider covering Wall Street at large.Prior to Insider he was a staff reporter at Forbes Magazine covering billionaires and their businesses. He's previously written and worked for the Associated Press, the Green Bay Press-Gazette, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, and the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism. He's a graduate of the University of Wisconsin and holds a master's in business and economic journalism from Columbia University. Selected recent stories:How our insatiable appetite for electricity is giving rise to traders who make money from power-grid bottlenecksBehind a Wall Street headhunter's rapid ascent lie accusations of harassment and abuseSchonfeld's growing pains: Ryan Tolkin reckons with his greatest challenge yet as returns dry up at the $13 billion hedge fundHow a California hedge fund bulldozed the state's labor laws to impose some of the harshest noncompetes on Wall StreetFear and loathing on Wall Street: Inside the paranoid, hyper-competitive onslaught to prevent quant traders from defecting to rivalsMillennium has quietly minted billions off of America's passive-investing craze. Now rivals are racing to catch up.The bubble has popped on the mighty index-rebalance trade, and the overcrowded strategy is wreaking carnage across hedge fundsInside the rapid rise and fall of Coatue's quant fund: How a 23-year-old Wharton wunderkind seized power, alienated employees, and blew a $350 million opportunityFor years, Chase and Citi credit cards offered a generous, under-the-radar benefit that protected customers. And then the bots arrived.