Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio jersey?
Ronkonkoma, New York, apparently.
A framed Yankees uniform, worn and signed by Joltin' Joe himself, is no longer hanging on the living-room wall of Rudy Giuliani's Manhattan apartment. On this, both sides of a contentious $148 million Georgia-election-worker defamation case agree.
On Thursday, some light was shed on what remains a point of dispute: why Giuliani has yet to surrender the DiMaggio jersey and other sports memorabilia, art, and furnishings to the election workers Ruby Freeman and Wandrea "Shaye" Moss, as ordered last month, along with the $5.7 million apartment itself.
Speaking during a federal court hearing in Manhattan, Giuliani's attorney Kenneth Caruso told a judge the jersey and other items removed from the apartment remained in a locked storage facility in the Long Island hamlet of Ronkonkoma.
The lawyer added, however, that Giuliani could no longer access the storage facility and therefore couldn't turn anything inside it over to Freeman and Moss, Freeman's daughter.
Caruso said the plaintiffs could pick the items up at the facility.
"The objects there are no longer in his possession," he told US District Judge Lewis Liman, adding that it was up to "the proprietors of the Ronkonkoma facility to turn it over."
A lawyer for Freeman and Moss, meanwhile, told the judge that he'd been unable to reach anyone at the storage facility, identified in court papers as the America First Warehouse.
A website for the America First Warehouse advertises a podcast called "The America First Podcast" and shares photos of past events hosted at the space with guests including Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, Chaya Raichik (the founder of Libs of TikTok), and Kellyanne Conway.
The venue has also hosted at least eight events in Giuliani's honor, including a fundraiser for his legal-defense fund.
An employee reached by phone on Thursday told Business Insider the warehouse was a "patriotic venue," not a storage facility. A business on the same lot, Corporate Transfer, is advertised as a storage facility.
The owner of both the America First Warehouse and Corporate Transfer, Joseph Verderber Jr., didn't immediately return a request for comment.
Giuliani's spokesperson didn't respond to a request for comment.
The former New York City mayor has yet to turn over any of the possessions he was ordered to last month to fulfill the $148 million defamation judgment, including a Mercedes once owned by Lauren Bacall, a diamond ring, and several luxury watches, the plaintiff's attorney Aaron Nathan said.
Giuliani must also turn over $2 million in legal fees he has previously said are owed to him by President-elect Donald Trump, money he said Thursday he still didn't have.
Nathan said Thursday that instead of complying with the order to surrender property, Giuliani had been "evasive" or "silent" while also moving cash around, including by opening bank accounts and forming a limited liability company.
"He no longer has a possession right over it," Nathan said. "We've asked over and over again where this stuff is. He refuses to answer."
The judge said that if Freeman and Moss believed that the items from the New York apartment — including sports memorabilia he referred to as "a couple of pictures, a shirt" — were improperly moved and that Giuliani was lying about not being able to access them, "then plaintiffs can move for contempt."
The judge added that the plaintiffs could move for a contempt finding if Giuliani failed to comply with any of his court orders.
"My client is not in possession of the property," Giuliani's lawyer responded, to which the judge answered: "He's not going to be in contempt if he's made attempts and it's impossible to comply with the order."
Asked after court what the holdup with the storage facility might be, Giuliani told BI he didn't know.
"All they do is keep jerking us around," he said, smiling.
Giuliani was ordered Thursday to provide the plaintiffs' lawyers with the keys and title to the Mercedes, which the former mayor had tried to keep by saying its value was under $4,000.
"His 54-year-old automobile is worth less than that," Caruso had said again on Thursday.
Giuliani was also ordered to continue working with the plaintiffs on getting access to the storage facility. He must also provide plaintiffs with co-op shares for the Manhattan apartment.
The judge had ordered Guiliani to turn over many of his assets, including the apartment, the DiMaggio jersey, the luxury wristwatches, and the Mercedes, on October 22.
Giuliani had attempted to declare bankruptcy, but a judge dismissed the case in July.
A federal jury in 2023 awarded Freeman and Moss $148 million to repair their lives after Guiliani peddled false claims that they manipulated ballots in the 2020 election during Trump's first attempt to return to the White House.
Giuliani repeatedly said Freeman and her daughter pulled up "illegal" ballots stashed in a suitcase and passed around a USB drive that contributed to Joe Biden winning in Georgia, a key state in his electoral victory.
The women received death threats and were subjected to harassment after Giuliani made his claims on social media and his podcast.
The Georgia state election board investigated the claims and cleared the women of wrongdoing.
