Science

Puffy 'cotton ball' clouds are a rocket launch's most common nightmare. Here's why they delayed SpaceX's historic flight.

spacex crew dragon falcon 9 demo 2 launchpad
The SpaceX Crew Dragon spacecraft sits atop a Falcon 9 booster rocket on Pad39A at the Kennedy Space Center in Cape Canaveral, Florida, May 29, 2020. Steve Nesius/Reuters
Read in app

SpaceX and NASA were forced to delay their first astronaut launch on Wednesday, largely because the sky held too many fluffy clouds.

The high-stakes demonstration flight, called Demo-2, is set to fly people in a commercial spacecraft for the first time ever. If successful, the mission would resurrect the US's capability to launch its own astronauts and kick off a new era of commercial space exploration.

SpaceX, which was founded by Elon Musk in 2002, designed and built its Crew Dragon spaceship with the help of NASA funding to shuttle astronauts to and from the International Space Station. It's currently perched atop SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket in Cape Canaveral, Florida.

The next launch attempt will be on Saturday at 3:22 p.m. ET. The same weather conditions clouded the skies all of Saturday morning, but forecasters say the clouds may clear before launch time. Mission commanders will watch the weather closely in the hours and minutes leading to liftoff.

nasa astronauts doug hurley bob robert behnken spacesuits launch complex 39a spacex demo2 demo 2 crew dragon test flight dress rehearsal may 23 2020 KSC 20200523 PH KLS03_0011_orig
NASA astronauts Douglas Hurley (left) and Robert Behnken (right) participate in a dress rehearsal for launch at the agency’s Kennedy Space Center in Florida on May 23, 2020, ahead of NASA’s SpaceX Demo-2 mission to the International Space Station.  Kim Shiflett/NASA

Mission commanders scrubbed Wednesday's scheduled launch just 17 minutes before liftoff, since storm clouds created unsafe weather conditions for the rocket and the two NASA astronauts inside the spaceship.

"You have the bubbling clouds out there — those big white puffy clouds that look like big cotton balls — those are cumulus clouds," Jason Fontenot, who oversees the team that monitors and forecasts weather for rocket launches at the 45th Weather Squadron, said in a call with reporters.

"Those provide the biggest threats when it comes to launching rockets," he added.

spacex crew dragon spaceship sunrise kennedy space center cape canaveral florida launchpad launch complex 39a elon musk twitter
The sun rises in Cape Canaveral, Florida, as SpaceX's Crew Dragon spaceship and Falcon 9 rocket await launch in May 2020.  SpaceX via Twitter

That's because the clouds' bubbliness comes from vertical development, which creates electric charge inside the cloud. 

"So if we launched near that cloud, we could potentially induce or trigger a lightning strike from that cloud," Fontenot said.

That happened to the Apollo 12 mission in 1969. The astronauts inside the rocket felt the lightning strike, and it disabled nine nonessential instrument sensors.

"Falcon/Dragon are designed to withstand multiple lightning strikes, but we don't think it would be wise to take this risk," Musk tweeted on Saturday.

Of the 10 lightning-related weather conditions that could scrub a launch, the presence of cumulus clouds is the most common.

"We had those hard requirements that when something hits, there's nothing we can do about it," Fontenot said of the weather restrictions. "So yes, it was kind of disappointing, but I'd much rather launch during better weather, and hopefully we'll get a chance on Saturday."

The 45th Weather Squadron projects a 50% chance of safe conditions for the upcoming attempt. The main concerns are rain, thunderstorm anvil clouds, and those puffy cumulus clouds.

'Scrubs are part of conducting spaceflight safely and successfully'

nasa astronauts doug hurley bob robert behnken spacesuits launch complex 39a spacex demo2 demo 2 crew dragon test flight dress rehearsal may 23 2020 EYvN3ynVcAETZUx
NASA astronauts Bob Behnken (left) and Doug Hurley wear their spacesuits during a dress rehearsal on May 23, 2020, ahead of NASA’s SpaceX Demo-2 mission to the International Space Station.  SpaceX via Twitter

If weather doesn't scrub the mission again on Saturday afternoon, the Falcon 9 will launch astronauts Bob Behnken and Doug Hurley to the space station. They will stay there for up to 110 days before the Crew Dragon brings them back to Earth.

"Scrubs are part of conducting spaceflight safely and successfully. During my last mission to [the space station], weather caught us too," Behnken tweeted on Friday. "We're ready for the next launch opportunity!" 

The last time the United States launched humans into space from American soil was in 2011, when the last space shuttle made its final voyage into orbit. Since then, NASA has relied on Russian Soyuz rockets to ferry its astronauts to and from the International Space Station, a practice that has become increasingly expensive and limited US access to the station.

But that could all change this weekend.

"It is a pretty surreal experience and I'm extremely grateful to be a part of this big moment in history," Fontenot said.

Read next

Morgan McFall-Johnsen was a science reporter at Business Insider. She covered climate change, weather, Earth sciences, and space, as well as health and medicine, environmental issues, and occasionally archaeology.Email her at mmcfalljohnsen@gmail.com and follow her on X @MorganMJohnsen.Expertise
  • Climate change and climate-crisis solutions
  • Extreme weather (heat, drought, floods, fires, hurricanes)
  • NASA and other space agencies
  • Commercial space industry (SpaceX, Blue Origin, satellite constellations)
  • Astronomy and physics (planets, galaxies, the sun, black holes, gravitational waves)
Morgan has interviewed astronauts aboard the International Space Station and published exclusive in-depth accounts of early COVID-19 outbreaks on cruise ships.She has appeared on NBC, Scripps News, Sirius XM, C-SPAN, and NPR to discuss climate change, extreme weather, Mars missions, the space race, and far-right extremism. She’s previously written for Backpacker Magazine, Outside Business Journal (formerly SNEWS), and Popular Science.She holds a Bachelor of Science in Journalism from Northwestern University, where she also studied environmental policy and French. She was a 2022 Logan Science Journalism Fellow at the Marine Biological Laboratory and a 2023 Columbia Energy Journalism Fellow.Popular stories