Politics

Trump indictment looms closer in NY; grand jurors in Stormy Daniels 'hush-money' probe expected back Wednesday

Donald Trump's former lawyer and fixer Michael Cohen, center, is joined by his attorney, Lanny Davis before Cohen's grand jury appearance in mid-March.
Donald Trump's former lawyer and fixer Michael Cohen, center, is joined by his attorney, Lanny Davis before Cohen's grand jury appearance in mid-March. Mary Altaffer/AP
Read in app

A Manhattan grand jury heard from yet another witness Monday in the New York "hush-money" investigation that could result in the historic indictment of former President Donald Trump.

The panel is expected to reconvene on Wednesday to continue its work.

On Monday, grand jurors heard more than two hours of testimony from Robert Costello, an attorney for Trump ally Rudy Giuliani. Prosecutors did not, however, request a rebuttal from Michael Cohen, their star witness in the probe, his lawyer, Lanny Davis, told Insider.

Instead, Cohen waited outside the grand jury room Monday, at the ready should he be called before the grand jury again to challenge Costello's testimony, Davis said.

Cohen, the prosecution's most important witness and most vocal advocate, did not end up having the final word in the grand jury room, as he had anticipated — at least not on Monday.

"Mr. Cohen was available for over two hours today, but we are pleased to report Mr. Cohen was not needed," Davis said in a statement. "Once again we repeat — the facts and documents speak for themselves. Facts do matter."

In an interview with MSNBC's Ari Melber on Monday, Cohen said he believed Trump's attorneys wanted Costello to testify before the grand jury because he was the only person willing to make "false statements" about Cohen's role in the hush-money payments.

"There's not another dope that's willing to put his backside on the line for Donald," Cohen said.

Costello said in an interview with the New York Times after his testimony that he told the grand jury that Cohen wasn't trustworthy. In his interview with Melber, Cohen struck back.

"I testified before seven congressional committees, the attorney general, district attorney — not one person has turned around so far and said that anything that I told them has not been accurate and truthful," he said.

A full day of work or more may await the panel, especially if testimony has not concluded. Marta Dhanis of Fox News tweeted Monday night that she had learned from two unnamed sources that another grand jury witness is indeed on tap for Wednesday. Insider could not immediately confirm that detail.

 

At the conclusion of testimony, the grand jury would then need to be "charged," the process when prosecutors explain the potential indictment count by count. Following the charge, the grand jurors would deliberate and vote.

Grand jurors frequently accomplish these tasks quickly, according to former Manhattan prosecutor John Moscow, who handled hundreds of white-collar criminal cases before going into private practice.

"The deliberation and vote can take five minutes," even in a complex case, he said.

The contents of the indictment would not become public until a judge unseals them. That unsealing typically happens at a defendant's New York Supreme Court arraignment, the public appearance at which not-guilty pleas are entered before a judge.

Cohen had said that prosecutors wanted him on-hand Monday as a possible rebuttal witness to his former legal advisor, Costello, who promised to tell grand jurors "the truth — what Michael Cohen failed to tell them," as he left for court in the morning, according to Law 360.

 

The top counts of any indictment are expected to be a series of low-level felony charges of falsifying business records, possibly reflecting any role Trump and others allegedly played in the payments being hidden from election authorities.

The $130,000 payment guaranteed that adult film actress Stormy Daniels would remain silent in the days before the 2016 presidential election and not go public about a 2006 sexual relationship she alleged she'd had with Trump.

Federal authorities have said the payment was an unlawful campaign contribution. In a 2018 guilty plea, Cohen admitted he wired the money to Daniels' lawyer "at the direction of the candidate" and for "purpose of influencing the election."

The grand jury has been meeting in secret since mid-January. 

Update — This story has been updated to remove a reference to the days of the week the grand jury meets. The grand jury had been meeting in secret, typically on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays.

Read next

Jacob Shamsian author profile headshot
Jacob Shamsian
Jacob Shamsian is a correspondent on Business Insider's Enterprise news desk. He is also a Global Reporter for Axel Springer.He was previously on BI's Legal Affairs desk, covering major litigation, courtroom trials, and the legal industry.Jacob has reported on the criminal trials of Donald TrumpGhislaine Maxwell, Sam Bankman-Fried, Sean "Diddy" CombsR. Kelly, and Anna Sorokin (AKA Anna Delvey), He's also covered blockbuster civil trials, including both E. Jean Carroll v. Trump trials, the New York Attorney General's fraud trial against TrumpSarah Palin v. The New York Times, and Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard.His stories have been cited in judicial rulings, lawsuits, letters from congressional committees, and in numerous media publications. He was a pool reporter in Donald Trump's Manhattan criminal trial.Jacob has been interviewed on CNN, the docuseries "Surviving R. Kelly," ABC's "Good Morning America," and BBC News, among other programs. His work has been cited by media outlets, including The New York Times, Bloomberg News, The Washington Post, Vanity Fair, and New York magazine. He's also written for GQ, The Awl, The New Republic, Entertainment Weekly, Time, and Modern Farmer.You can reach Jacob on Signal at JacobShamsian.07.
Headshot photo of Laura Italiano
Laura Italiano
Laura Italiano reported on legal affairs and the courts, focusing on lawsuits and prosecutions affecting business, innovation, and technology. She was following the scores of cases being pursued both by and against the new Trump administration, including those relating to DOGE and the ongoing federal anti-trust actions against Apple, Amazon, Google, Meta, and Ticketmaster.Laura is based in New York City, where she covers high-profile federal and state defendants, including Luigi Mangione, Sean "Diddy" Combs, Charlie Javice, and the Alexander brothers.Laura worked at three New York City tabloids — Newsday, The Post and (freelance) The News — before scrubbing off the newsprint and joining Insider in February 2022.Check out Insider's source guide for tips on sharing information securely.