Transportation

The tariff fight over the world's biggest plane makers is heating up after the US claimed Boeing's rival Airbus was given 'market-distorting subsidies'

Airbus Boeing
An Airbus A350-1000 and a Boeing sign at the 2019 Paris Air Show. REUTERS/Pascal Rossignol
Read in app

The US is threatening even more tariffs on European Union goods after a new World Trade Organization ruling, claiming that the French aircraft maker Airbus, Boeing's biggest rival, was given "market-distorting subsidies."

The US put tariffs on $7.5 billion worth of EU goods in October as part of a long-running case in which it alleges Airbus was given improper subsidies to help it gain market advantage in Europe.

The EU and the US have accused each other for over a decade of improperly subsidizing their jet makers, which are the two biggest in the world. The WTO has found that both the EU and the US were giving improper subsidies.

The WTO ruled on Monday that the EU and some of its member countries had "failed" to "take appropriate steps to remove the adverse effects" of subsidies on the US.

Christian Scherer, Airbus Chief Commercial Officer, speaks during a news conference for the delivery of the first Fiji Airways A350 XWB airliner at the aircraft builder's headquarters of Airbus in Colomiers near Toulouse, France, November 15, 2019. REUTERS/Regis Duvignau
Christian Scherer, Airbus' chief commercial officer.  Reuters

Airbus had argued that the US should reduce its tariffs on EU goods, which include Airbus products, because US complaints about subsidies to its A380 program were no longer relevant as the plane model was being retired.

But the WTO said it "rejected the European Union's argument that Airbus' announcement to 'wind down' the A380 program at present achieved the withdrawal of the French, German, Spanish, and UK" subsidies.

US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer painted the WTO ruling in harsh terms, saying: "In light of today's report and the lack of progress in efforts to resolve this dispute, the United States is initiating a process to assess increasing the tariff rates and subjecting additional EU products to the tariffs."

"Strong action is needed to convince the EU that its interest lie in eliminating these market-distorting subsidies now and in the future so that our industries can compete on a level playing field," he said in a statement, the Financial Times reported.

The EU accused the WTO on Monday of "serious legal errors" in the case, the Financial Times reported.

robert lighthizer
US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer.  Jacquelyn Martin/AP Images

"We consider that the panel has made a number of serious legal errors in its assessment of EU compliance," a European Commission representative said.

"The report also contains statements concerning workable ways to comply with the WTO rules on subsidies that would be very problematic for a larger part of the WTO membership to comply with."

The commission might also appeal "to have these legal errors corrected," according to the Financial Times.

Lighthizer's statement is likely to add an extra layer of tension to the NATO summit, which kicked off in London on Tuesday.

US President Donald Trump said at a NATO press conference on Tuesday that "we're going to tax Airbus" and that it would "be very good for Boeing."

Read next

Sinéad Baker's face on a grey background
Sinéad Baker
Sinéad Baker is a Military and Defense Correspondent based in Business Insider's London bureau, writing about Russia's invasion of Ukraine and NATO actions.Sinéad most often covers soldiers' experiences, military strategy, battlefield developments, weapons systems, the defense industry's response, and the impact on NATO and European security, and geopolitical decisions that surround the Ukraine war. She has reported from NATO’s frontlines and around Europe,  has interviewed multiple prime ministers and defense ministers, has appeared on BBC News and The Guardian's politics podcast, and has been cited by Congressional hearings.Sinéad has also extensively covered US politics and previously led Business Insider's breaking news coverage from London.Sinéad previously completed a master's degree in investigative journalism at City, University of London, and has written for The Guardian, The Observer, and TheJournal.ie. Sinéad is the former editor of the multi-award-winning The University Times in Dublin.Expertise
  • Experiences of soldiers in Ukraine, including battlefield developments and tactics
  • Western military responses to the war, and lessons they should learn
  • New weaponry built for and in response to the war 
Email Sinéad at sbaker@bjinnox.com or find her on X.