Finance

A growing alternative data company helps hedge funds determine if CEOs are lying using CIA interrogation techniques

cia director gina haspel
CIA Director Gina Haspel in May. Alex Wong/Getty
Read in app

After a year of returns so poor that it prompted investors to redeem more than $33 billion, hedge fund managers are hungry for anything that gives them an edge on competitors and the market.

This has resulted in rapid expansion of alternative data providers, which mine for useful and actionable info in nontraditional ways.

One of these companies, Amenity Analytics, wants to cut the time analysts and portfolio managers spend poring over earnings-call transcripts by getting straight to the point: Some CEOs are not completely honest.

By using natural-language-processing software to review companies' transcripts, press releases, and public comments, Amenity assigns sentiments to key phrases and points. For example, the technology will identify words like "expanding" as positive while "limit" and "damage" are flagged as negative.

But the software goes a step beyond that as well, according to the Amenity Analytics cofounder Nate Storch, who was previously a portfolio manager at the New York-based hedge fund Talpion Fund Management as well as a mergers-and-acquisitions banker at Morgan Stanley. The tool also picks out phrases and euphemisms executives use to couch bad news, something the firm calls its "deception score."

While the deception tracker does not give a numerical rating to the different phrases executives use, it does assign one of 10 descriptions to each deceptive "event." Examples include selective memory — "when an executive claims not to be able to remember information" — and negative clichés that "are overused and betray lack of original thought."

To train the software to detect deceptive language, Amenity built "publicly available" interrogation methods used by the CIA and others into the system, Storch said.

Read more: Nasdaq is buying a company that offers hedge funds obscure data to give them a trading edge

The goal of the technology is to read body language through written text.

"For us, it's really a spotlight for analysts to say 'this is where you need to be digging,'" Amenity's marketing director, Mark Zepf, told Business Insider in an interview at the firm's Manhattan office.

With hedge funds down 4% on average last year and investors pushing portfolio managers to justify their fees, alternative data providers like Amenity have blossomed. According to AlternativeData.org, there are more than 400 providers providing datasets to 78% of the hedge fund industry. The industry group predicts that in 2020 hedge fund managers will spend more than $1.7 billion on alternative data, up from $400 million in 2017.

Amenity has hired aggressively to match the increased interest, tripling its workforce from 20 employees at the beginning of 2018 to 60 employees now, split between offices in New York and Tel Aviv, Israel.

Read more: Hedge funds spend billions of dollars a year on alternative data. A new product is hoping to give investors an edge.

The company has attracted notable names in the software space, with Intel investing in the 3-1/2-year-old company when Amenity was raising seed capital and holding a board seat. Nasdaq, Evercore, and Barclays are clients that have posted research using Amenity's software.

Storch said his firm was not trying to replace widely used data providers like Bloomberg or Thomson Reuters but instead sought to amplify the information provided by them.

"It's all the stuff that's not in your Bloomberg," he said. "It's an analyst for your analyst," he said.

Sign up here for our weekly newsletter "Wall Street Insider," a behind-the-scenes look at the stories dominating banking, business, and big deals.

Read next

Bradley Saacks
Bradley Saacks
Bradley Saacks covers hedge funds and other asset managers for Business Insider from New York. He first wrote about the multi-trillion-dollar industry for Business Insider from New York in late 2018, after spending two years covering mutual funds for the Financial Times' trade publication, Ignites.He left Business Insider for a little over a year, starting in mid-2022, and worked as a business reporter for Semafor, a media startup. He rejoined Business Insider in 2023, this time in the publication's London office, and has since relocated back to New York. A graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill's School of Media and Journalism, he was the recipient of the O.J. Skipper Coffin Award, which is given to the top graduating senior in the reporting track.During his time at Business Insider, he has broken news on the biggest names in hedge funds, including Paul Singer's Elliott Management, Ken Griffin's Citadel, Seth Klarman's Baupost Group, and more. He is interested in telling stories about the people behind the scenes who are driving big changes at the biggest firms. He can be reached on WhatsApp and Signal at +1 919 816 5537.Notable stories include: