Real Estate

Take a tour of Derek Jeter's unique lake-side castle that has been on the market for 5 years and is headed to auction

Derek Jeter Castle Mansion
Wright Brothers Real Estate; Eric Espada/Getty Images
Read in app

At one point, the New York Yankees superstar shortstop Derek Jeter was the king of New York, so it's only fitting that the five-time World Series champion lived in a castle.

Jeter purchased his 4.01-acre Greenwood Lake, New York, property for $425,000 in 2003 and converted it into a fortress. Now that the MLB royal has relocated to Florida, he does not need the stunning compound and decided to list it with Diane Mitchell of Wright Bros. Real Estate Inc.

The castle, which is roughly 45 miles northwest of Yankee Stadium, appeared on the market in June 2018 and was listed for a whopping $14.8 million. Jeter's lakeside palace — affectionately dubbed the "Gem on the Lake" in the official listing — couldn't find a buyer so it went up for auction with a starting bid of $6.5 million.

Check out photos of Jeter's home below:

The legendary shortstop and Hall of Famer Derek Jeter had a castle fit for a king when he was playing for the New York Yankees.

Jeter home 1
Realtor.com

The gorgeous property is in Greenwood Lake, New York, roughly 45 miles northwest of Yankee Stadium.

Jeter home 2
Realtor.com

It's so large that there is a bridge connecting one side of the property with the other.

Derek Jeter house
Hudson Valley Tours / Vimeo

The stone home — known as Tiedemann Castle — comes complete with fountains and gardens around the outside.

Jeter house 14
Wright Brothers Real Estate

And it has a beautiful waterfall.

Jeter home 25
Realtor.com

There's a replica of the Statue of Liberty, too.

Jeter home 26
Realtor.com

It's a beautiful place to take a nice walk ...

Jeter house 11
Wright Brothers Real Estate

... or sit and watch boats pull into the marina.

Jeter house 10
Wright Brothers Real Estate

The house's grandest feature — a multistory turret — sits alongside the river.

Jeter home 4
Realtor.com

It looks even more impressive up close.

Jeter house 7
Wright Brothers Real Estate

Although the walk to the top seems like a serious trek ...

Jeter house 9
Wright Brothers Real Estate

... the view from the top is definitely worth it.

Jeter house 8
Wright Brothers Real Estate

In total, the property boasts nearly 700 feet of shoreline.

Jeter home 28
Realtor.com

So it makes sense that many of the rooms in the home have gorgeous views of the water.

Jeter home 29
Realtor.com

Now let's take a look inside.

Jeter home 5
Realtor.com

The grand entryway features wooden archways, a winding staircase, and a piano.

Jeter home 6
Realtor.com

Here's another look from the other side.

Jeter home 7
Realtor.com

The house boasts 12,590 square feet.

Jeter home 13
Realtor.com

It's filled with spacious rooms and tall ceilings.

Jeter home 24
Realtor.com

The home was built in 1903, and Jeter has special ties to the property.

Jeter home 30
Realtor.com

Source: Realtor.com

His maternal grandfather grew up in the castle after he was adopted by the Tiedemann family.

jeter home 31
Realtor.com

Source: Realtor.com

This kitchen — in the main house — is one of the five kitchens spread throughout the two-parcel property.

Jeter home 8
Realtor.com

With a breakfast nook, an island, and a big kitchen table, this kitchen looks like a gathering spot in Jeter's castle.

Jeter house 2
Wright Brothers Real Estate

Here's another kitchen.

Jeter home 20
Realtor.com

It's really a chef's dream.

jeter house 5
Wright Brothers Real Estate

And here's a third kitchen.

Jeter home 19
Realtor.com

This one has a great view of the lake.

Jeter home 21
Realtor.com

And there are plenty of cozy dens in the main house.

Jeter home 9
Realtor.com

This library overlooks some of the gardens surrounding the house.

Jeter home 10
Realtor.com

The house has six bedrooms ...

Jeter home 11
Realtor.com

... seven full bathrooms ...

jeter house 3
Wright Brothers Real Estate

... and five half baths.

Jeter home 12
Realtor.com

The office is complete with a large desk and a conference table.

Jeter home 14
Realtor.com

But the house is also equipped with an awesome game room for when it's time to kick back and relax.

Jeter home 15
Realtor.com

And it has a bar that's great for hosting.

Jeter home 17
Realtor.com

This den is probably big enough to fit the entire Yankees roster.

Jeter home 16
Realtor.com

It's the perfect place to catch a game or watch a movie.

jeter house 4
Wright Brothers Real Estate

This dining room may have been the site of team dinners.

Jeter home 18
Realtor.com

There's a home gym where you can get in some MLB-caliber reps.

jeter gym
Wright Brothers Real Estate

Stepping outside feels like stepping back in time.

Jeter home 22
Realtor.com

But the infinity pool is as modern as it gets.

Jeter home 23
Realtor.com

Check out the aerial view.

Jeter infinity pool
Hudson Valley Tours / Vimeo

There's an outdoor kitchen nearby.

Jeter house 12
Wright Brothers Real Estate

Jeter's house also has a hot tub ...

Jeter hot tub
Hudson Valley Tours / Vimeo

... and a giant bell. Frankly, we aren't sure what that's for.

Jeter hot tub
Hudson Valley Tours / Vimeo

There's plenty of garage space for Jeter's luxury cars.

Jeter house
Wright Brothers Real Estate

And there's a jungle gym for the kids.

Jeter house 6
Wright Brothers Real Estate

The home really feels like a medieval castle in some spots.

Jeter house 13
Wright Brothers Real Estate

After nearly a year and a half for sale, Jeter pulled the listing "for the winter months," per the real estate agent selling the home. The agent said at the time that it would be returning to the market shortly.

Jeter home 27
Realtor.com

Source: CBSSports.com

Now take a tour of Michael Jordan's 56,000-square-foot home that's on the market:

Michael Jordan house
Concierge Auctions; Stephan Savoia/AP

Read next

Cork was a correspondent for Insider's sports desk.Previously, he was a contributor at MLB Trade Rumors, and he has written for Yahoo Sports, Deadspin, and The Hardball Times. He has authored chapters in three books, including "The Hardball Times 2009 Season Preview." Cork's work has been featured on ESPN's "SportsCenter" and "Mike & Mike," "Any Given Wednesday with Bill Simmons," ESPN.com, BBC, Yahoo, USA Today, Sports Illustrated, Drudge Report, the Washington Post, the Kansas City Star, the Houston Chronicle, and the Dallas Morning News, among others.He is a graduate of the University of Iowa and holds a doctorate from Fordham University.Here is a selection of his work:Under Armour hit the jackpot on its Jordan Spieth betGary Woodland once took his pants off to hit a shot and learned a funny lesson about product endorsementWe tried the alcohol diet Tom Brady put Rob Gronkowski on, and it was a lot harder than we imaginedThe University of Texas spent $7 million remodeling their football locker room and the results are jaw-droppingStephen Curry has replaced LeBron James as the best basketball player in the worldEx-NBA player who made $60 million explains what really happens to your money when you sign an 8-figure contractHere's Michael Jordan's 56,000-square-foot house in Chicago, and why it's still on the market after 6 yearsMayweather beat McGregor with a TKO in the 10th round! Here are the big moments everybody will be talking aboutPerfect conditions at Cowboys-Patriots game helped create incredible picturesWe've been using Alexa in a car for 6 months and it's the best infotainment system we've ever used.
Meredith Cash was a sports reporter for Business Insider covering all games played on a field, court, rink, diamond, or gridiron with a specific focus on women's sports.A Knicks fan who grew up north of New York City, Meredith has moved on to greener pastures as one of the Cameron Crazies — and yes, she did live in a tent to get tickets. She graduated from Duke University in 2018 and continues to hope for the best but expect the worst from her New York sports teams.Send Meredith tips and follow her on X: @mercash22.