Tech

Elon Musk still needs a 'Twitter sitter' to review Tesla tweets, judges rule

Elon Musk.
Elon Musk, Tesla CEO. Michael Gonzalez/Getty Images
Read in app

Elon Musk has lost an appeal against an SEC agreement that landed him with a "Twitter sitter."

The "Twitter sitter" clause means that Musk's Tesla-related tweets must be reviewed by another company executive. This clause came as a result of a 2018 tweet where Musk said he had "funding secured" to take Tesla private at $420 a share.

Musk has been fighting back against the clause for some time, saying it violated his freedom of speech.

However, on Monday a panel of three judges dismissed those claims, saying that the court saw "no evidence to support Musk's contention that the SEC has used the consent decree to conduct bad-faith, harassing investigations of his protected speech."

Musk wrote his infamous "funding secured" tweet to the 22 million Twitter followers he had at the time. However, the deal failed to materialize and investors subsequently accused him of manipulating Tesla's share price.

As part of the SEC settlement, Musk and Tesla also each agreed to pay $20 million worth of fines and Musk agreed to step down as chair of Tesla's board.

In a September brief, Musk's team urged the courts to throw out the "Twitter sitter" agreement, calling it a "government-imposed muzzle" restricting the CEO's freedom of speech, Reuters reported.

In February, Musk's attorney Alex Spiro said the restriction was an unconstitutional infringement of the CEO's free-speech rights, per CNBC.

In the Monday ruling, the judges disagreed. "To the contrary, the record indicates that the SEC has opened just three inquiries into Musk's tweets since 2018," they said.

Representatives for Musk did not immediately respond to Insider's request for comment, made outside normal working hours.

Read next

Beatrice Nolan was a tech reporter on the business news team in the UK. She joined Insider in January 2022 as a fellow on Business Insider's careers desk. Beatrice covered tech and the future of work, with a focus on artificial intelligence. Some of her stories and early experiments with ChatGPT are widely cited. Beatrice has also discussed her work covering AI trends on panels and radio shows, including NPR.She was based in Business Insider's London office and graduated from the University of  York with a bachelor's degree in English.Featured Articles:Artists say AI image generators are copying their style to make thousands of new images — and it's completely out of their control.ChatGPT was a black swan eventFinland is the world's happiest country, but Finns say we're confusing happiness for something elseThe world is splitting between those who use ChatGPT to get better, smarter, richer — and everyone elseThis man used AI to write and illustrate a children's book in one weekend. He wasn't prepared for the backlash.ChatGPT has only been around for 2 months and is causing untold chaosTwo professors who say they caught students cheating on essays with ChatGPT explain why AI plagiarism can be hard to proveChatGPT wrote college application essays. Admissions professionals said they passed for essays written by students but wouldn't have a chance at any top colleges.College professors are considering creative ways to stop students from using AI to cheatChatGPT wrote my cover letters. Here's how recruiters responded.