Tech

One of Wall Street's top internet analysts says Facebook and Instagram user satisfaction just dropped to all time lows

Mark
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg Drew Angerer/Getty Images
Read in app

People are increasingly unhappy with their experience on Facebook and Instagram, a top Wall Street internet analysts warned after surveying thousands of users.

Over the past year, Facebook saw the most precipitous drop-off in user satisfaction, according to a research note from Mark Mahaney of Evercore ISI. Of nearly 2,000 US users polled recently, 24% said they are "extremely unsatisfied" with Facebook. Evercore also found a record low number of users to be very satisfied with the platform, coming in at 27% of those surveyed.

Facebook, operator of the world's largest social network, ranked the worst in satisfaction of all platforms included in the survey, including Pinterest, TikTok, Snapchat, and Twitter. The latter was the next worst in satisfaction, but was still 8 percentage points ahead of Facebook.

"Facebook's satisfaction scores have trended downwards over time," Mahaney and colleagues wrote.  In more recent years, Facebook's user satisfaction has skewed positive, so "this iteration marks a significant step down," the analysts added.

Instagram, which is owned by Facebook, saw a decrease in user satisfaction, too, although people overall are much happier with that platform than Facebook. While only 8% of users surveyed said they are "extremely or very unsatisfied" with Instagram and 43% said they are very satisfied, Evercore called this a "deterioration" for the platform, as it shows satisfaction at "an all-time low."

Mark Mahaney
Mark Mahaney  CNBC/Screenshot

Nevertheless, Facebook and Instagram remain the two most widely used social-media platforms, with nearly 3 billion people on Facebook and roughly 1 billion on Instagram worldwide. Evercore found that both platforms look to be maintaining increased usage spurred by pandemic lockdowns last year.  

As for the negative experiences people are having, Evercore did find a slight increase in people saying they plan to use both platforms less in coming months. But the brokerage firm noted that such claims never usually match an actual decline in usage. 

The bank pointed to possible explanations for the decline in satisfaction with Instagram, including increased advertising on the platform and within its increasingly popular Stories feature. It did not mention note a string of recent news reports about the platform's negative implications for teen mental health and its lax enforcement of standards for high-profile account holders. 

The bank didn't explain Facebook's falling user satisfaction. The platform has faced numerous public revelations and media reports about its operations in recent years, such as its central role in spreading toxic political discourse and misinformation.

Read next

Kali Hays was a Tech Correspondent at Business Insider covering the major social media platforms like Meta, Twitter, and Snap. Her reporting covered major changes and the internal culture at these companies, the founders and executives who run them, and business developments and products. Hays also wrote frequently about AI and emerging trends and shifts in the tech industry overall. Her work has been widely cited, including by the FTC in an investigation into Elon Musk’s takeover of Twitter, and she has appeared as an expert on NBC, CBS, the BBC and elsewhere. Her exclusive reporting and scoops include:Meta's Facebook Messenger hit with layoffs amid ongoing 'efficiency' pushLayoff angst looms over Meta employees as they face tough performance reviews and ongoing reorgsMeta aiming to reveal and demo Orion, its first true AR glasses, at its fall developer conferenceMeta's Responsible AI team shrinks amid layoffs and restructuring, even as the company goes all-in on AIMeta updates RTO policy with stricter mandate, saying workers may lose their jobs if they don't show up 3 days a weekLeaked documents from Mark Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan's charity include a tacit admission that their biggest bet on education reform was a flop'He is in war time': Mark Zuckerberg's desperate, last-ditch attempt to remake himself — and MetaOpenAI is expected to release a 'materially better' GPT-5 for its chatbot mid-year, sources sayOpenAI's employees were given 2 explanations for why Sam Altman was fired. They're unconvinced and furious.AI is killing the grand bargain at the heart of the web. 'We're in a different world.'Jack Dorsey warns Block employees of coming job cuts: 'The growth of our company has far outpaced the growth of our business.'Elon Musk is considering taking X out of Europe amid EU compliance investigationLeak: Elon Musk said he wants X to be a dating app, too, in an all-hands meeting on the anniversary of his Twitter takeoverLinda Yaccarino, Elon Musk, and the most difficult CEO job on earthElon Musk's Twitter races to build a live video service as it woos right-wing media personalitiesElon Musk is moving forward with a new generative-AI project at Twitter after purchasing thousands of GPUsSnap begins a new round of layoffs with staffers expecting more next weekEvan Spiegel proclaims 'social media is dead' in leaked memo, predicts Snap is about to 'transcend' the smartphoneSnap workers say they're being closely 'tracked' to enforce compliance with the RTO mandateHow Snap misread big threats from TikTok and Apple and lost its chance at becoming an advertising giant